You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
rendered-views: interactive userConfig smoke test on the current CLI (gates the fleet sweep) #3604
The userConfig mechanism has a real bug history (enable-prompt and persistence issues, roughly v2.1.86 through v2.1.210). Docs are current at v2.1.252, and a wave-1 probe on CLI 2.1.251 verified the unset path only (an unset user_config reference reaches a skill body as the literal token, the documented behavior the resolution ladders detect). The interactive set-value flow could not run in the remote container, so per the owner-approved Brief amendment the full test rides this issue and gates the fleet sweep (#3603).
Test, on a machine with the interactive /plugin dialog: set the visualization plugin's medium option to a non-default value, confirm the value substitutes into plugins/visualization/skills/visualize/SKILL.md's rung-2 line at invocation, confirm persistence across CLI restart, and confirm clearing the option restores literal-token unset behavior. Record CLI version and outcome here, then unblock #3603.
Triage outcome: human-gated (capability blocker, not a decision)
This needs a human because of what it requires, not because anything is undecided. The test must be run through the interactive plugin dialog on a machine that has one. A remote container has no such dialog, which is exactly why the wave-1 probe could only verify the unset path and why the full test was moved onto its own issue. No amount of briefing makes this delegable to an agent in a headless environment.
The test procedure itself is fully specified in the body and needs nothing added.
Verification (2026-09-06)
The setup checks out. The convention document exists with its wave-1 adoption section, the exemplar surface that migrated in wave 1 is in place and carries the rendered-views wiring, and the shared chrome reference exists in that plugin's reference directory. So the mechanism under test is real and shipped, and this test is the gate on multiplying reliance on it.
Blocking relationship recorded
A native dependency edge now records that #3603 is blocked by this issue. That was previously stated only in prose in both bodies. The fleet sweep will not surface as available work until this test is done, which is the intended behavior: the sweep multiplies reliance on the configuration dial across a dozen surfaces, and the dial has a real bug history through roughly v2.1.86 to v2.1.210.
What the runner needs to do
On a machine with the interactive plugin dialog, on the current CLI:
Set the visualization plugin's medium option to a non-default value.
Confirm the value substitutes into that skill's tier-2 line at invocation.
Confirm the value persists across a CLI restart.
Confirm clearing the option restores the unset behavior, where the reference reaches the skill body as a literal token.
Record the CLI version and the outcome in a comment here. The version matters: the documented behavior is current as of a later version than the one the wave-1 probe used, and the bug history makes the version part of the result rather than a footnote.
On completion, if the flow works, remove the dependency edge so #3603 becomes available. If it does not, report what failed here, because the sweep's tier ladder depends on the dial being reliable and a failure changes the sweep's design rather than merely delaying it.
Host run. Interactive claude under a detached tmux session with a throwaway CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR, to drive the /plugin userConfig set, persist and clear test; blocked at the login screen before /plugin was reachable.
CLI version: 2.1.312 (Claude Code).
What ran:
tmux new-session -d with CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR set to an empty throwaway directory under /home/kyle/worktrees/host-run-3604/, then the real claude binary by absolute path under timeout 600, driven with tmux send-keys and read with tmux capture-pane.
The TUI drove reliably under tmux: the welcome screen and theme picker rendered, and Enter advanced to the next screen.
The next screen was the first-run "Select login method" prompt. A fresh config dir carries no login, and the subscription login is a browser OAuth on the owner's account. Copying the host's existing credentials into the throwaway dir is a credential move this run is not allowed to make, so the run stopped there.
Against the four steps of the 2026-10-01 comment:
Set medium to a non-default value in /plugin: not run (login screen comes before /plugin).
Value substitutes into the rung-2 line of plugins/visualization/skills/visualize/SKILL.md at invocation: not run.
Value persists across a CLI restart: not run.
Clearing the option restores literal-token unset behavior: not run.
Not a TUI-driving failure: keystrokes and captures worked. The blocker is auth isolation. The test needs either an attended session that logs the throwaway config dir in once (any subscription account), or a run against an already logged-in config whose pluginConfigs the run is allowed to change and restore.
#3604 host run: interactive userConfig smoke test (real config)
Date: 2026-11-01
Host: WSL2 (Linux), real logged-in ~/.claude (no throwaway CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR), run under the owner's authorization for this run
CLI: claude --version → 2.1.316 (Claude Code)
Plugin under test: visualization@melodic-software 0.13.3, user scope (the active install for the working directory)
Target line: ~/.claude/plugins/cache/melodic-software/visualization/0.13.3/skills/visualize/SKILL.md:117, which reads 2. **Configured preference**. `${user_config.medium}`. Claude Code text-substitutes
What ran
Snapshot of ~/.claude/settings.json and ~/.claude.json taken before any change. pluginConfigs existed only in settings.json and had no visualization@melodic-software entry. ~/.claude.json had no pluginConfigs.
The real CLI ran in a detached tmux session, timeout 900 claude --permission-mode auto, working directory /home/kyle/worktrees. It was driven with tmux send-keys and read with tmux capture-pane -p.
Each check used this prompt: /visualization:visualize Do not render anything and run no tools. Reply only with the exact text of the line in your skill body that begins "2. **Configured preference**", verbatim in a code block.
The baseline check alone had a leading terminal argument. That argument is rung 1 and does not affect the text
substitution in rung 2.
Evidence for each check comes from two places: the model's reply on screen, and a grep of that session's transcript
(~/.claude/projects/-home-kyle-worktrees/<session>.jsonl), which records the skill body as it was injected.
Three CLI processes ran: the set session, a restart, and a final restart after the option was cleared.
Baseline before step 1, option unset: both the reply and the transcript showed the literal token 2. **Configured preference**. `${user_config.medium}` .
Results
#
Step
Verdict
Evidence
1
Set medium to a non-default value in /plugin
pass
Path: /plugin → Installed → search visualization → Configure options. The dialog showed Preferred delivery medium ◀ auto ▶ (it displays the declared default even when nothing is stored). → terminal → Save configuration. The CLI printed Configuration saved. and ran /reload-plugins on its own. settings.json then held pluginConfigs["visualization@melodic-software"] = {"options":{"medium":"terminal","thin_context_prompt":"auto"}}
2
Value substitutes at invocation into the rung-2 line
pass
Same session after the save. Reply: 2. **Configured preference**. `terminal`. Claude Code text-substitutes. The transcript grep showed `terminal` in place of the token
3
Value persists across a CLI restart
pass
/exit, then a new process. The reply and the transcript both showed `terminal`. The Configure options dialog in the new process also showed ◀ terminal ▶
4
Clearing restores the literal-token unset behavior
pass, with a finding
The dialog has no clear or reset control; it only cycles the enum (auto, terminal, file, artifact, hosted). Choosing auto and saving stored "medium":"auto", not an unset key. To clear it, the CLI was exited and settings.json was restored from the snapshot. The semantic diff before the restore showed that only the two visualization@melodic-software option paths differed. After a fresh process started, the reply and the transcript both showed the literal 2. **Configured preference**. `${user_config.medium}` again, matching the baseline
Findings
The dialog cannot unset an option. After any save, the option holds a stored value. Returning to the default
stores "auto". The only way back to the literal-token state is editing settings.json by hand. The skill's rung 2
already treats a literal token, an empty value and auto the same way, so the visible behavior matches. The stored auto was not invoked in this run.
One save writes every option. Saving with only medium changed also stored thin_context_prompt: "auto", the
declared default for that option.
The CLI rewrites settings.json when it saves. After the save the file's key order changed (a large text
diff, no value changes outside the plugin entry). Restoring the snapshot bytes put the original order back.
Config diff summary
~/.claude/settings.json: during the run, only pluginConfigs["visualization@melodic-software"].options.{medium,thin_context_prompt}
differed in value. It now matches the pre-run snapshot byte for byte (cmp is clean). The file is rendered by a
chezmoi modify_ script, which touches only the guardrails key under pluginConfigs. chezmoi apply was not run.
~/.claude.json: still has no pluginConfigs. The changed keys are CLI bookkeeping that every launch writes, left as
they are: numStartups, usage counters for this plugin and skill (pluginUsage, skillUsage), caches and tips.
Folder trust: projects["/home/kyle/worktrees"].hasTrustDialogAccepted went from unset to true. The first launch
required accepting the trust dialog to run in that folder. It is the one lasting change to user config besides the
option under test. It was left in place because live sessions write ~/.claude.json.
Background plugin auto-update: during the run the CLI updated three plugins on its own (knowledge 0.31.1, playbooks 0.25.3, harness-ops 5.1.1); the reload after the save applied them. The test did not cause this. visualization stayed at 0.13.3 throughout.
No credential files were copied. No other user config was changed by the test.
Target labels: remove attended. #3603 is unblocked, provided its acceptance counts clearing the option by hand.
Through the dialog alone, the nearest state is a stored auto.
Closing as completed. The attended run on 2026-11-01 (Claude Code 2.1.316) passed all four steps through the interactive /plugin dialog (#3604 (comment)):
the medium value saved;
it substituted into the rung-2 line of plugins/visualization/skills/visualize/SKILL.md;
it persisted across a restart;
clearing it brought back the literal ${user_config.medium} token.
One finding carries into #3603: the dialog has no unset control. Choosing the default stores "auto", and only a hand edit of settings.json removes the key. Visualization's rung 2 already treats the literal token, an empty value and auto the same way (SKILL.md:117-120), so the tier ladder stands. The convention contract does not state that rule, and a stored auto was not invoked in this run, so #11361 gets a done-when line for it. As the 2026-10-01 decision says, the blocked-by edges from #3603 and #11361 to this issue are removed.
Activity
feat(visualization): adopt the rendered-views doctrine (html-effectiv…
claude commentedon Sep 6, 2026
Generated by Claude Code
claude commentedon Sep 6, 2026
This was generated by AI during triage.
Triage outcome: human-gated (capability blocker, not a decision)
This needs a human because of what it requires, not because anything is undecided. The test must be run through the interactive plugin dialog on a machine that has one. A remote container has no such dialog, which is exactly why the wave-1 probe could only verify the unset path and why the full test was moved onto its own issue. No amount of briefing makes this delegable to an agent in a headless environment.
The test procedure itself is fully specified in the body and needs nothing added.
Verification (2026-09-06)
The setup checks out. The convention document exists with its wave-1 adoption section, the exemplar surface that migrated in wave 1 is in place and carries the rendered-views wiring, and the shared chrome reference exists in that plugin's reference directory. So the mechanism under test is real and shipped, and this test is the gate on multiplying reliance on it.
Blocking relationship recorded
A native dependency edge now records that #3603 is blocked by this issue. That was previously stated only in prose in both bodies. The fleet sweep will not surface as available work until this test is done, which is the intended behavior: the sweep multiplies reliance on the configuration dial across a dozen surfaces, and the dial has a real bug history through roughly v2.1.86 to v2.1.210.
What the runner needs to do
On a machine with the interactive plugin dialog, on the current CLI:
Record the CLI version and the outcome in a comment here. The version matters: the documented behavior is current as of a later version than the one the wave-1 probe used, and the bug history makes the version part of the result rather than a footnote.
On completion, if the flow works, remove the dependency edge so #3603 becomes available. If it does not, report what failed here, because the sweep's tier ladder depends on the dial being reliable and a failure changes the sweep's design rather than merely delaying it.
Generated by Claude Code
docs(rendered-views): park interactive userConfig smoke (#3604) (#4989)
kyle-sexton commentedon Sep 29, 2026
Reopened: it was closed by cursor[bot] with no smoke-test result recorded; the gate is unmet.
docs(conventions): drop the parked userConfig smoke record from rende…
19 remaining items
github-actions commentedon Oct 27, 2026
The triage sweep dispatched intake triage for this issue (attempt 1 of 2).
kyle-sexton commentedon Oct 28, 2026
Host run. Interactive
claudeunder a detached tmux session with a throwawayCLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR, to drive the/pluginuserConfig set, persist and clear test; blocked at the login screen before/pluginwas reachable.CLI version: 2.1.312 (Claude Code).
What ran:
tmux new-session -dwithCLAUDE_CONFIG_DIRset to an empty throwaway directory under/home/kyle/worktrees/host-run-3604/, then the realclaudebinary by absolute path undertimeout 600, driven withtmux send-keysand read withtmux capture-pane.Against the four steps of the 2026-10-01 comment:
mediumto a non-default value in/plugin: not run (login screen comes before/plugin).plugins/visualization/skills/visualize/SKILL.mdat invocation: not run.Not a TUI-driving failure: keystrokes and captures worked. The blocker is auth isolation. The test needs either an attended session that logs the throwaway config dir in once (any subscription account), or a run against an already logged-in config whose
pluginConfigsthe run is allowed to change and restore.Target labels: add none; remove none.
kyle-sexton commentedon Nov 1, 2026
#3604 host run: interactive userConfig smoke test (real config)
~/.claude(no throwawayCLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR), run under the owner's authorization for this runclaude --version→2.1.316 (Claude Code)visualization@melodic-software0.13.3, user scope (the active install for the working directory)~/.claude/plugins/cache/melodic-software/visualization/0.13.3/skills/visualize/SKILL.md:117, which reads2. **Configured preference**. `${user_config.medium}`. Claude Code text-substitutesWhat ran
~/.claude/settings.jsonand~/.claude.jsontaken before any change.pluginConfigsexisted only insettings.jsonand had novisualization@melodic-softwareentry.~/.claude.jsonhad nopluginConfigs.timeout 900 claude --permission-mode auto, working directory/home/kyle/worktrees. It was driven withtmux send-keysand read withtmux capture-pane -p./visualization:visualize Do not render anything and run no tools. Reply only with the exact text of the line in your skill body that begins "2. **Configured preference**", verbatim in a code block.The baseline check alone had a leading
terminalargument. That argument is rung 1 and does not affect the textsubstitution in rung 2.
Evidence for each check comes from two places: the model's reply on screen, and a grep of that session's transcript
(
~/.claude/projects/-home-kyle-worktrees/<session>.jsonl), which records the skill body as it was injected.Baseline before step 1, option unset: both the reply and the transcript showed the literal token
2. **Configured preference**. `${user_config.medium}`.Results
mediumto a non-default value in/plugin/plugin→ Installed → searchvisualization→ Configure options. The dialog showedPreferred delivery medium ◀ auto ▶(it displays the declared default even when nothing is stored). →terminal→ Save configuration. The CLI printedConfiguration saved.and ran/reload-pluginson its own.settings.jsonthen heldpluginConfigs["visualization@melodic-software"] = {"options":{"medium":"terminal","thin_context_prompt":"auto"}}2. **Configured preference**. `terminal`. Claude Code text-substitutes. The transcript grep showed`terminal`in place of the token/exit, then a new process. The reply and the transcript both showed`terminal`. The Configure options dialog in the new process also showed◀ terminal ▶auto,terminal,file,artifact,hosted). Choosingautoand saving stored"medium":"auto", not an unset key. To clear it, the CLI was exited andsettings.jsonwas restored from the snapshot. The semantic diff before the restore showed that only the twovisualization@melodic-softwareoption paths differed. After a fresh process started, the reply and the transcript both showed the literal2. **Configured preference**. `${user_config.medium}`again, matching the baselineFindings
stores
"auto". The only way back to the literal-token state is editingsettings.jsonby hand. The skill's rung 2already treats a literal token, an empty value and
autothe same way, so the visible behavior matches. The storedautowas not invoked in this run.mediumchanged also storedthin_context_prompt: "auto", thedeclared default for that option.
settings.jsonwhen it saves. After the save the file's key order changed (a large textdiff, no value changes outside the plugin entry). Restoring the snapshot bytes put the original order back.
Config diff summary
~/.claude/settings.json: during the run, onlypluginConfigs["visualization@melodic-software"].options.{medium,thin_context_prompt}differed in value. It now matches the pre-run snapshot byte for byte (
cmpis clean). The file is rendered by achezmoi
modify_script, which touches only the guardrails key underpluginConfigs.chezmoi applywas not run.~/.claude.json: still has nopluginConfigs. The changed keys are CLI bookkeeping that every launch writes, left asthey are:
numStartups, usage counters for this plugin and skill (pluginUsage,skillUsage), caches and tips.projects["/home/kyle/worktrees"].hasTrustDialogAcceptedwent from unset totrue. The first launchrequired accepting the trust dialog to run in that folder. It is the one lasting change to user config besides the
option under test. It was left in place because live sessions write
~/.claude.json.knowledge0.31.1,playbooks0.25.3,harness-ops5.1.1); the reload after the save applied them. The test did not cause this.visualizationstayed at 0.13.3 throughout.Target labels: remove
attended. #3603 is unblocked, provided its acceptance counts clearing the option by hand.Through the dialog alone, the nearest state is a stored
auto.kyle-sexton commentedon Nov 2, 2026
Closing as completed. The attended run on 2026-11-01 (Claude Code 2.1.316) passed all four steps through the interactive
/plugindialog (#3604 (comment)):mediumvalue saved;plugins/visualization/skills/visualize/SKILL.md;${user_config.medium}token.One finding carries into #3603: the dialog has no unset control. Choosing the default stores
"auto", and only a hand edit ofsettings.jsonremoves the key. Visualization's rung 2 already treats the literal token, an empty value andautothe same way (SKILL.md:117-120), so the tier ladder stands. The convention contract does not state that rule, and a storedautowas not invoked in this run, so #11361 gets a done-when line for it. As the 2026-10-01 decision says, the blocked-by edges from #3603 and #11361 to this issue are removed.This was generated by AI.